Stack Overflow virgin

I posted my first question on Stack Overflow today and already it’s had a couple of replies. I can see how Stack Overflow could become a little addictive because it has elements of a game built into it. For starters, you build up reputation points, which you get from other people by providing answers, but you need some reputation points before you can start giving points to others, and you can’t comment on other people’s answers until you’re above a certain rep level.

Have a listen to Hanselminutes Show 134 to hear Jeff Atwood, CEO of Stack Overflow, talking about the concept of the site and what they’ve done to make it an appealing place for software developers to hang out. The bit that really struck a chord with me was when he described Stack Overflow as sort of an antidote to Experts’ Exchange, the latter being a site that really rubs me up the wrong way because of its underhand tactics. There are so many times I’ve searched for something technical on Google and found a hit that looks like it might provide the answer I was looking for but I don’t notice it’s at Experts’ Exchange until I get there and discover the details are obscured because the site is run as a private club, which I refuse to join.

I like Stack Overflow. The only thing I don’t like about it is that I think its search facility is very weak right now. If you want to find stuff it’s best to use Google, like this:

http://www.google.com/search?q=site:stackoverflow.com/questions YOUR QUERY

For example:

http://www.google.com/search?q=site:stackoverflow.com/questions online help

The other aspect of it is that, if you’re not a programmer – or even if you are – it can be an intimidating place for the newcomer. You have to brace yourself and be prepared to be told you’re an idiot and should go away and never darken the doors of Stack Overflow again. But, in some ways, that’s not altogether a bad thing. It’s intended to be a games room for professional programmers – it’s not designed for just anybody to go and find an answer to any old thing. But, unlike Experts’ Exchange, everyone’s allowed to come in and wander around and listen in on the conversations. However, if you try answering a question you’re not qualified to answer, or you start asking questions that should have been asked elsewhere, then you can expect the regulars to give you a hard time.